Alexy, robert, constitutional rights and proportionality april 19, 2014. Pdf download a theory of constitutional rights free. Robert alexy, proportionality and rationality, in proportionality. Pdf a theory of constitutional rights download full. In any country where there is a bill of rights, constitutional rights reasoning is an important part of the legal process. The relevance of this work, therefore, is founded especially on the assumption that the expansion of constitutional rights and robert alexys theory can contribute to this matter. This volume gathers leading figures from legal philosophy and constitutional theory to offer a critical examination of the work of robert alexy. Alexys theory of constitutional rights and the problem of. Mattias kumm juian rivers deserves credit not only for a text which does full justice to alexys renowned lucidity, but also for an introduction which argues persuasively for the relevance of alexys understanding of constitutional rights. The core claim relating to the structure of rights is that constitutional rights are principles and that proportionality analysis is necessarily at the heart of reasoning about what principles require in real contexts. This lacuna has been filled by law, rights and discourse. Balancing, and the cult of constitutional rights scholarship, the canadian journal of law and jurisprudence, 10. A theory of constitutional rights robert alexy julian rivers. May 16, 2017 robert alexy a nonpositivistic concept of constitutional rights.
This book analyses the general structure of constitutional rights reasoning under the german basic law. Constitutional rights and proportionality openedition journals. Constitutional rights, democracy, and representation. There are two basic views concerning the relationship between constitutional rights and proportionality analysis. Law, morality, and the existence of human rights by robert. The relations and interconnections between and among the three pillars are identified. Constitutional rights and proportionality by robert alexy ssrn. Robert alexy, born in 1945, studied law and philosophy at the georgaugustuniversity in gottingen. Oct 24, 2002 a theory of constitutional rights by robert alexy, 9780198258216, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. In recent work, robert alexy has endorsed radbruchs formula and made it a centerpiece of his theory of law. Constitutional rights, democracy, and representation 199 ricerche giuridiche, 3, 2, 2014, pp. Robert alexy, a theory of constitutional rights philpapers.
An international journal of jurisprudence and philosophy of law, 124, pp. In considering the features of constitutional rights reasoning, the author moves from the doctrine of proportionality. Pavlakos praises alexy for having developed a systematic philosophy covering most of the key areas of legal philosophy. In an extended introduction the translator argues for its applicability to the british constitution, with particular reference to the human rights. Robert alexys classic work reconstructs the reasoning behind the jurisprudence of the german basic law and in doing soprovides a theory of general application to all jurisdictions where judges wrestle with rights adjudication. Includes an extensive discussion of the german case law on constitutional rights, of value to comparative constitutional lawyers. The contributions explore the issues surrounding the complex relations between rights, law, and morality and reflect on alexys distinctive work on these issues. The system formed by these five concepts is highly complex. Alexys theory is based on an analysis of constitutional rights as principles, which, he argues, are fundamentally different from rules. Constitutional rights, balancing, and rationality alexy.
Radbruch, five minutes of legal philosophy 1945, ojls. As more and more countries adopt human rights legislation and accede to international human rights agreements, and as the european union introduces its own bill of rights, judges struggle to implement these rights consistently and sometimes the. Revus journal for constitutional theory and philosophy of law 2014 22. A discussion of alexys theory as a model for adjudication. Critical legal studies comparative law economic analysis international legal theory legal history philosophy of law sociology of law. A theory of constitutional rights by robert alexy, 9780198258216, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide.
The first maintains that there exists a necessary connection between constitutional rights and proportionality, the second argues that the question of whether constitutional rights and proportionality are connected depends on what the framers of the constitution have actually decided, that is, on positive law. Jan 27, 1986 in any country where there is a bill of rights, constitutional rights reasoning is an important part of the legal process. Constitutional rights, balancing, and rationality robert alexy abstract. Pdf a theory of constitutional rights download full pdf. It has been frequently remarked that the works of robert alexy form a system. The contributions explore the issues surrounding the complex relations between rights, law. At first glance, this can be read as an acknowledgement of the. Pdf robert alexys a theory of constitutional rights. Robert alexy s classic work reconstructs the reasoning behind the jurisprudence of the german basic law and in doing so provides a theory of general application to all jurisdictions where judges wrestle with rights adjudication. Essays on robert alexys legal philosophy political theory. The paper discusses robert alexy s theory of constitutional rights with particular reference to his theory of principles and the distinction he draws between constitutional rules and constitutional principles fundamental human rights.
Dec 10, 2009 it would be a mistake for constitutional scholars of any tradition not to engage this book seriously. Discursive constitutionalism is a theory that stems from the connection among five different concepts. Robert alexy, radbruchs formula, and the nature of legal. A theory of fundamental rights tarello institute for. The core claim relating to the proper domain or scope. A classic work of constitutional theory presenting an influential account of the. Robert alexy, the construction of constitutional rights. As more and more countries adopt human rights legislation and accede to international human rights agreements, and as the european union introduces its own bill of rights, judges struggle to implement these rights consistently and sometimes the reasoning behind them is lost. The principles theory of constitutional rights is confronted with numerous objections. The critical analysis of the structural elements of alexys theory is combined with an assessment of its applied relevance, with special attention being paid to the uk human rights act and the fundamental rights protection in the european. In short, this is a good and useful book not only to those interested in the ideas of robert alexy, but also to those with more general worries such as the relation between law and morality, the criteria to evaluate adjudication grounded in human rights, the structure of legal reasoning and the investigation on which sort of theory of law would be able to ground legal objectivity. A theory of constitutional rights paperback robert.
Pdf a discussion of robert alexys theory of constitutional. It then takes up two objections to this approach raised by jurgen habermas. The first maintains that there exists a necessary connection between constitutional rights and proportionality, the second argues that the question of whether constitutional rights and proportionality are connected depends on what the framers of the constitution have actually. Constitutional rights expansion and contributions from robert.
A theory of legal argumentation the theory of rational discourse as theory of legal justification robert alexy ruth adler and neil maccormick. Mattias kumm compares alexys work to dworkins and claims that their works exhibit a holistic or systembased approach to the study of law. By robert alexy translated by julian rivers oxford. Procedural formal principles can override substantive constitutional rights principles only in connection with other substantive principles id. My reply to this is that absolute, objective, or necessary moral elements do exist, for human rights exist, and human rights exist because they are justifiable. A theory of constitutional rights download ebook pdf, epub. Arguing fundamental rights explores the pathbreaking theory of constitutional rights of robert alexy. It would be a mistake for constitutional scholars of any tradition not to engage this book seriously. Suggested citation alexy, robert, law, morality, and the existence of human rights march 2012. It deals with a wide range of problems common to all systems of. Issue 3 this volume helps us to gain a better understanding of the implications of alexys theory of legal argumentation, but also to identify.
Robert alexys philosophy of law as system oxford scholarship. The contributions explore the issues surrounding the complex relations between rights, law, and morality and reflect. Robert alexy this book will be of central interest to all legal and constitutional theorists, and human rights scholars. A classic work of constitutional theory presenting an influential account of the nature and scope of constitutional rights. In a theory of constitutional rights robert alexy provides an account of the structure and domain of constitutional rights. Institutionalized reason the jurisprudence of robert alexy ed. Robert alexy, on constitutional rights to protection, in legisprudence 3 2009, pp.
Constitutional rights and proportionality by robert alexy. This does not mean, however, that provisions giving expression to constitutional rights cannot also express rules or elements of rules. Robert alexy teoria dos direitos fundamentais in the present study, the conflict of the right to the environment with the fundamental rights of property and of the free initiative is appreciated. Norms conferring constitutional rights are most prominent here. A theory of constitutional rights paperback robert alexy.
Robert alexy s classic work reconstructs the reasoning behind the jurisprudence of the german basic law and in doing soprovides a theory of general application to all jurisdictions where judges wrestle with rights adjudication. The first maintains that balancing is both irrational and a danger for rights, depriving them. A theory of constitutional rights download ebook pdf. The paper discusses robert alexys theory of constitutional rights with particular reference to his theory of principles and the distinction he draws between constitutional rules and constitutional principles fundamental human rights. The critical analysis of the structural elements of alexys theory is combined with an assessment of its applied relevance, with special attention being paid to the uk human rights act and the fundamental rights protection in the european union before and after the charter of fundamental. Examining the practice in other jurisdictions can be a valuable guide.
Presentation from the conference human rights and the controversy about the nature of law. Robert alexy a nonpositivistic concept of constitutional. In the postscript to a theory of constitutional rights, i have formulated a law of combination which runs as follows. Robert alexys classic work reconstructs the reasoning behind the jurisprudence of the german basic law and in doing so provides a theory of general application to all jurisdictions where judges wrestle with rights adjudication. This classic work of constitutional theory analyzes the general structure of constitutional rights and their judicial application.
Includes an extensive discussion of the german case law on constitutional rights, of. Ustavna prava i proporcionalnost constitutional rights and. These are alexys doctoral thesis, a theory of legal argumentation. A theory of legal argumentation robert alexy oxford. According to alexy, fundamental human rights as protected by the german basic law are principles. It says that the optimization thesiswithout which principles theory would not be principles theoryleads to a ballooning out of constitutional rights, leading in turn to an. The first maintains that there exists a necessary connection between constitutional rights and proportionality, the second argues that the question of whether constitutional rights and proportionality are connected depends on what the framers of the constitution have. Constitutional rights expansion and contributions from. However, in his further discussion constitutional rights tend to be principles in reality. Addresses fundamental issues of law that are as important to practitioners as they are to legal theorists and students of law. The rules of the rationality of practical discourse in the. Robert alexy a nonpositivistic concept of constitutional rights.
1390 1291 566 385 1090 602 968 796 41 284 15 44 893 1422 65 1078 2 443 1202 191 396 792 751 531 501 1133 1104 211 1471 1070 1318 1344 47 422 449 286 1091 979 265 619 772 983 1232 307 340 1274 1176 1061 765 132